What did you observe?
Students were not shy to talk about their puzzle and engage in conversations about how they picked their puzzle and artifact. Most students were excited to watch us solve their puzzle, and were even more excited when we solved it. With all the students that I've talked to, they all seemed pretty happy to be doing their puzzle and well-prepared to answer any questions or to give hints.
What benefits did you notice?
I saw good relationships between the pairs that work together as they work together to explain their puzzle and give hints. Another benefit is that students are learning to express themselves and to explain the puzzle patiently so that we would understand. What I also found very interesting is that the students also gave positive feedback ('Well done!', 'You got it!', 'Good job!', or even 'Good try! Can you think of another way?'), so they're learning to be encouraging and guiding people step by step to solve their problem.
What might you emulate in your own classroom?
I like the idea of having students pick a puzzle and presenting it to help the audience solve it. I'd like to make it a short presentation in my own class, so students may to present the puzzle, guide the audience to solve the puzzle, and to just learn to help others learn. I also like how the students made a "poster" to present it, I think it's a good idea.
What problems did you notice?
One problem I noticed was that some students would run away from their station, so some stations would either only have one person or no one at all. Some students even negotiate on taking turns while the other goes away. I feel like this is a team project and they should be working together at all times; however, it is hard with such a big venue since students get distracted and wander off.
What might you change if you were to lead a math fair?
I think I'd try to include more different types of puzzles for students to pick from. There were quite a few repetitions, but, overall, the students all had their own unique way of presenting their poster which still made it interesting even though we had already done a similar problem.
Great observations Cindy -- thanks!
ReplyDelete