One thing I hated in high school math class was proofs. Math proofs were taught by deduction, and there were so many of them, I remember just memorizing them all just for the tests and exams. As a kinesthetic learner, I would have much preferred to be taught by dynamic geometry. I would've been able to understand the proofs quicker and enjoy it more. I believe with the advance of technology and the increasing number of students owning digital devices, dynamic geometry programs such as GeoGebra would get students attention really quickly and they'd have lots of fun playing with it. However, I believe that there are students that prefer to have a deeper understanding of math proofs, and would benefit more from deductive reasoning.
With that being said, I feel both deductive and dynamic geometry proofs may convince students. It only depends on students' preference and learning styles.
How or when would you use both kinds of demonstrations or proofs in your classes? Why?
For my long practicum, I will be teaching the grade 9s
Similarity & Scale Factors. I'd spend most of my time using dynamic geometry proofs to give students the chance to play around with Geogebra and to understand it by themselves. Once students have clearly understood the idea, I'd use deductive reasoning to briefly explain it just so students know where it came from. I feel that students will be more able to pick up the proofs easily after the dynamic geometry demonstration.
John Mason's three levels of proofs are interesting and useful. Since everyone thinks and understands things differently, I think for one to really understand a concept, one would have to be able to explain or proof a concept in (multiple) ways that others will understand. Therefore, one should be able to prove it themselves, prove it to a friend, and then to a sceptic. This can be easily done in class, where students can be given time to write out the proof by themselves for a few minutes, then to pair up with a partner, and, lastly, to prove it to someone at home or someone that is not in the classroom for homework.