Sunday, November 20, 2016

Dave Hewitt: Arbitrary and Necessary

"Arbitrary'" refers to an idea that is just to be accepted as it is, without having any reason to why it is like that. "Necessary", on the other hand, can be understood and made sense of by working out from something one already knows. I think a teacher would have to put much thought into deciding what's "arbitrary" and "necessary". For me to decide what is arbitrary and what's necessary, I feel that I should try to put myself in my students' shoes and try to approach the problem like it is completely new to me. I would probably also ask myself many "why's" to how it works and try to make sense out of it with what I already know.

As a student, I've always preferred to know and remember an idea or concept through understanding rather than memorising. So, when prepping for a lesson, I always think of questions students might ask when I teach. After reading the article, I think I'll have more questions for myself when planning a lesson. I always try to link new content with their prior knowledge so they can remember it better because they understand it. Unfortunately, not everything can be understood and by everyone. Some arbitrary ideas are needed to make it easier for some concepts. For example, I may think of many ways, such as drawing pies, to help students understand why a half and a half will give a whole, but I'll never be able to explain why the numerator is always on top of the denominator if a student were to tell me she prefers to read the fraction from the bottom to top.

1 comment:

  1. Interesting comments, Cindy! The example about the positioning of the numerator and denominator is about an arbitrary mathematical convention -- one could imagine other ways of writing fractions (although this is the one that has become the accepted format). It does take some thinking to figure out what students could work out on their own using reason, via well-designed mathematical activities. It's well worth doing this though! I think that your own preference for understanding will help you value your students' understanding.

    ReplyDelete